COTW: Growing spread between Shiller & reported P/E ratios

April 29, 2019

The price-to-earnings ratio is a common valuation ratio derived by dividing the price per share of an individual stock or stock index by its earnings per share. There are several measures of earnings that can be used in the calculation, all with their own benefits and drawbacks.  The most common version of the ratio relies on the most recent 12-months of reported headline earnings. This measure has the benefit of being based on audited results, making it more reliable and consistent over time, however, the potential volatility in earnings resulting from non-recurring one-off charges makes it less relevant for an individual stock or for stocks in general during a recession.  As a result, investors may use forward estimates of operating earnings over the next 12 months. This approach has the benefit of factoring in anticipated earnings growth, but numbers will be misleading at inflection points in the profit cycle. A third common measure of earnings involves a cyclical-adjustment made by taking inflation-adjusted earnings over the prior ten years (the price is also inflation-adjusted in this version of the ratio).  This measure was developed by Robert Shiller and introduced during the Dot-Com bubble when it was cited as evidence that the stock market was overvalued.  The adjustment to earnings results in a far more stable and slow-moving denominator, which smooths out the cyclicality in margins and profits over time. While imperfect, the Shiller P/E has the benefit of the highest correlation (inverse) with future realized long-term returns.


The chart below shows the spread between two of these ratios — the Shiller (cyclically-adjusted) and reported P/E — over time. The spread today is approximately 9x, reflecting a Shiller P/E of 31.1x less a reported P/E of 22.2x.  Historically, spikes in this spread have coincided with temporary and unsustainable spikes in profit margins, making stocks appear cheaper than they are. These episodes have also often marked the peak of profits cycles and bull markets.  While there have been notable false positives from this signal, most notably in the mid to late 1990s, we believe investors should at least consider the sustainability of corporate profit margins in the coming years.




SpringTide Partners, LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor with the state of Illinois and other states jurisdictions where required. Registration with the SEC or any state securities authority does not imply a certain level of skill or training. All information contained herein is for informational purposes only and does not constitute a solicitation or offer to sell securities or investment advisory services. All investing carries risk including risk of principal loss. All statements made on this website are opinions of SpringTide Partners, LLC and are subject to change. SpringTide Partners, LLC assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of the data included. Statements made on website shall not constitute investment advice.

Share on Twitter
Please reload

White PNG.png
SpringTide Partners
200 West Superior Street, Suite 200
Chicago, Illinois 60654
T  312 620 6362
  • White Twitter Icon
  • White LinkedIn Icon

Manager submissions? Submit info here

The information contained in SpringTide Partner's website is of a general nature and for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, tax or legal advice. These materials reflect the opinion of SpringTide Partners as of the date produced and are subject to change at any time without notice due to a variety of factors, including changing market conditions or tax laws.  Where data or analysis is presented that is prepared by third parties, such information will be cited. These sources have been deemed to be reliable by SpringTide but no guarantee can be made as to their accuracy.  Any links to third party websites are offered for use entirely at your own discretion. SpringTide Partners is separate and unaffiliated from any third parties listed herein and is not responsible for their products, services, policies or the content of their websites. All investments are subject to varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that the future performance of any specific investment, investment strategy or product referenced directly or indirectly in this website will be profitable, perform equally to any corresponding indicated historical performance levels, or be suitable for your portfolio. Past performance is not an indicator of future results.

© 2019 SpringTide Partners. All Rights Reserved.